My Favorite NYC Bookstores

One of the things that I love most about NYC (which will surprise exactly no one): the bookstores. This is a city still full of independent bookshops that each have their own unique charm: there’s the old creaky ones, the “hip,” modern ones, the musty used bookstores full of history, and even the big, spacious Barnes and Nobles stores which I still love. I could while away many hours just browsing and wandering around a good bookstore (and often do, on days off). Where I used to live in the suburbs there were four bookstores within driving distance…and over the years, each and every one went out of business (a Barnes and Noble did open at one point, but it was a 45 minute drive away). I found that to be pretty sad, and so I have a big appreciation for living in a place that provides people with plenty of bookstores to browse whenever the mood strikes. Yes, books are way cheaper on Amazon, but shopping online just can’t compete with the pleasure and relaxation to be had by spending time browsing real, physical books in a well-stocked bookstore. And personally (though I do buy some books on Amazon), I feel good putting my money towards supporting these brick and mortar institutions. Read on to see my favorites:


The Strand is probably the first place that comes to mind when you think of NYC bookstores. It’s been around since 1927 and lived on what was then called “Book Row,” a stretch of six city blocks that contained 48 bookstores! Can you imagine? I would have been in heaven! The Strand is all that remains of Book Row today. The store was founded by 25 year old entrepreneur Ben Bass, and he named it after a street in London where forward-thinking book publishers and literary figures of the day congregated. The Strand is one of my favorite places to find gently used books (especially hardcovers) for an amazing price. It’s got character and charm that you simply won’t find anywhere else, and it’s one of those New York institutions that are part of what makes this city so great.

Strand at the Club Monaco Flagship: Flatiron

The Strand also has a shop-in-shop located within the Club Monaco Flagship on Fifth Avenue in the Flatiron district. I LOVE this location! They have a fantastic selection of novels and gorgeous fashion/photography books, and as you can see, the design details in this location are just too gorgeous. The fireplace with the gorgeous flowers, architectural details, and gilded mirror is always a welcome sight, and you can browse while sipping coffee from the attached Toby’s Estate. This is really one of my favorite places in the city.

McNally Jackson is what I had in mind when I mentioned “hip” bookstores. This spot is bright, clean, and modern. They carry a large selection of magazines with beautiful photography, like Kinfolk and Cereal, and they have a great selection of fiction, nonfiction, cookbooks, design tomes, and much more spread out over two stories. The attached coffee shop is a great place to sit down and peruse your new reads while sipping coffee and checking out the well-dressed, trendy downtown crowd that frequents McNally Jackson and other Nolita hotspots.

The Corner Bookstore: Upper East Side

The Corner Bookstore resides in a charming (admittedly, astronomically pricy) enclave of the Upper East Side known as Carnegie Hill, and it provides a small, but highly curated selection of books. The bookstore has been around since 1976 and lives in a space that was formerly occupied by a pharmacy for almost 50 years. They offer a wide selection of children’s books since there are many private schools in Carnegie Hill. I love this bookstore for it’s one-of-a-kind, neighborhood-store atmosphere. It’s tiny, charming, and so New York City.

Three Lives & Company: West Villageย 

This is another one, similar to The Corner Bookstore, that I just can’t help but loving because it’s so tiny, it’s so full of character, and it’s so New York. This warm, welcoming little spot is located in a quiet, unassuming, tucked-away corner of the West Village, and I’ve ducked in many times this winter to escape from the chill and just peruse their charming selection of books. The floors are creaky, the staff is friendly, the collection well-curated, and it’s just the coziest little place. If there were more bookstores like this in the world, I would be a very happy camper. It also happens to be the perfect place to while away the time if you’re waiting to get in to brunch at Jeffrey’s Grocery or Joseph Leonard on a busy weekend morning (both places that I highly recommend, despite the waits!).

Shakespeare and Company: Upper East Side

I consider this my “neighborhood” bookstore, and I just love it here. It’s conveniently located right near the subway, and it’s always very quiet and peaceful. You can browse uninterrupted and it’s bright, clean, and well-organized. I also love that I have little fear of this place closing, as they serve both Hunter College, across the street, and Marymount Manhattan, a few blocks away.

Rizzoli: (EDITOR’S NOTE: Happily, Rizzoli is now re-opened at 1133 Broadway in NoMad!).

Rizzoli was another bookstore that I loved when I first moved into the city. If the name sounds familiar, it’s because Rizzoli is a big producer of coffee table books – and their flagship store here in the city specialized in gorgeous, large coffee table tomes covering a variety of topics. It was very close to Central Park and housed in a beautiful, old-New York building with three stories. I thought the store had a really special atmosphere – just very cozy, quiet, and dignified…a haven where you could forget about all of the hustle and bustle outside and feel like you were back in the New York City of Edith Wharton’s time. Sadly, this location closed, and apparently the beautiful old building supposedly lacked the distinction that would have allowed it to be landmarked – according to the Internet, it’s been demolished (I can’t bring myself to walk by, it’s too depressing). Happily, a new locationย is opening in the spring. I’m still nostalgic for the old one, since it was in a bit more of an out-of-the-way location, whereas the new one is going to be smack dab in the middle of the busy Madison Square Park area. I don’t know if the new building is going to have the character of the old one, or if the quiet, cozily enveloping atmosphere that the old Rizzoli possessed will be present, but either way, it’s great that it’s re-opening – and the bustling nature of it’s new neighborhood will hopefully ensure that it stays open!

Kitchen Arts and Letters: Upper East Side

Kitchen Arts and Letters is the cutest little shop that exclusively sells books and magazines devoted to food and drink – cookbooks, foodie memoirs, food writing, culinary magazines, and the like. This is such a cozy little spot and as a big fan of food writing, I couldn’t love this place more!

The Mysterious Bookshop: Tribeca

As you can tell by my love for Kitchen Arts and Letters, I find nothing to be quite so charming as a “theme” bookshop – which is why I’m kind of obsessed with The Mysterious Bookshop in Tribeca. As you may have surmised, it’s a bookshop entirely devoted to mysteries, thrillers, whodunits, and the like.

Book Culture: Upper West Side

Book Culture is a mainstay of the Upper West Side – a large, bright space and perfect for kids, as they have a whole children’s section on the lower floor.

Crawford Doyle Booksellers: Upper East Sideย (EDITOR’S NOTE: Sadly, Crawford Doyle is now closed)

Crawford Doyle is another charming, small, independent bookstore on the Upper East Side that’s just a cozy, warm, little haven. To me it’s an UES version of Three Lives (same creaky floors), and they have a great selection within a welcoming atmosphere. Charmingly, they also have the current version of the NYT Sunday Book Section hung up on the wall for you to peruse while you’re there, if you’re interested in seeing what the bestseller list is looking like that week. The shop has a lot going for it but my favorite aspect might be the vintage typewriter in the window, in which they slip a quirky or thought-provoking message that changes periodically. I love checking what it says every time I have the occasion to walk by. This was the first time I saw it and remains my favorite message so far:

I know I sound like a broken record, but the other week I walked into Crawford Doyle and it was just so cold out, and the bookstore was so warm and cozy, and those floors were so creaky (clearly I have a weird obsession with creaky old floors), and I couldn’t help but marvel at how lucky I feel to live here. To live in a place where there’s not just one independent bookstore (which in itself would be a marvel these days), but multiple bookstores! It’s just one of many things that makes me love this city, and make me feel so constantly lucky to get to live here. People have a lot of complaints about NYC (the expense, the subways, the crowds, this and that), but I feel like this is the one area in my life where I see the positives and am relatively blind to the negatives. I’m naturally more of a “glass half empty” person (not a good quality), but when it comes to NYC I’m like a person in love – I only seem to see the good parts, and not the faults. I consider myself lucky for that, and lucky to live in a place that I adore.

Leave a Comment

  1. Anonymous wrote:

    I feel the same way about NYC! After living here for years, where could I possibly go??

    Published 2.23.15 · Reply
  2. I also love the Strand within Club Monaco. It's beautiful! I'll have to check out some of your other recommendations on my next visit to NYC! While I do buy plenty of books on Amazon or online, I agree there's something great about actually spending time browsing in a bookstore!

    Published 2.23.15 · Reply
  3. I love this write-up you did because I also love the independent bookstores here in New York! There's another independent bookstore on the Upper West Side (112th between Broadway & Amsterdam) that's a sweet little gem and worth checking out. I used to go to letter writing and tea events they hosted there. ๐Ÿ™‚

    Published 2.23.15 · Reply
  4. Nnenna wrote:

    I loved this post! I do feel lucky that there are so many great bookstores here in NYC. The Strand is definitely one of my favorite places in the city (and probably in the world). I've never been to the Strand within Club Monaco, which is silly because I work right around there. From what I've seen, it looks like a really pretty spot. I must go soon!

    Published 2.24.15 · Reply
  5. Nikki wrote:

    I love roaming local bookstores (or, you know, the book section at Targetโ€ฆ) These all look fantastic!


    Published 2.24.15 · Reply
  6. THK wrote:

    Great roundup! If I could add one more to the list it would have to be bookbook on Bleeker. Good selection, great sales, and next to tons of wonderful restaurants. You've got to check it out!

    Published 2.24.15 · Reply
    • Thanks for the rec! I've seen that but haven't gone in, not sure why. Can't wait to check it out ๐Ÿ™‚

      Published 2.26.15 · Reply
  7. Alison @ Peacoat Diaries wrote:

    Always a bit of a risk leaving a comment on a post that’s months old, but hoping you’ll see it…

    If you find yourself in Brooklyn, check out my favorite bookstore: Book Court on Court Street in Cobble Hill. Wonderful staff, incredible selection, great events, super charming location. And then if you’ve over there, walk down the street about 3 blocks to Community Book Store — it’s a super old school kind of book store but worth a visit. Amazing inventory — it almost looks like a hoarder situation, but it’s so fun to dig through the piles and the owner is quite a character, fun guy to chat with. And plenty of good eats in the neighborhood (Lobo is a favorite) — book shopping always makes me hungry!

    Published 12.13.15 · Reply
    • York Avenue wrote:

      Thanks for your comment Alison! I think I have heard of Book Court. It sounds amazing and I know Cobble Hill is supposed to be gorgeous…I would love to visit and definitely need to do so. Community Book Store sounds great too! I love old hoarder-ish bookstores ๐Ÿ™‚

      Published 12.13.15 · Reply
  8. Just the kind of post I wanted to read!!! I’ve got a holiday to NYC coming up in a little over a month’s time, and all your New York recommendations are just the best! Especially this one. I am such a sucker for books that my husband is tired of me weighing down all our bags with the weight of books whenever we travel. And I have this thing of picking up a book from a bookstore in every city that I travel to. I can’t wait to explore all these bookstores (and also NYC) real soon!!!!!!

    Published 3.11.16 · Reply